Lollipop, magic mushroom, or Benedetti's unmentionable, it's certainly not the right avatar for Kojak. His can only be a Mythos bottle, or preferably a (large) collection of empties.
Surely, Kojak, you must have plenty of photos from which you can cut out the Mythos bottles and send the extract to Mike. If not, and if there are any Chat Page members still on the island, perhaps we'd better commission them to do a photo shoot.